Saturday, April 18, 2015

Matthysse vs. Provodnikov: prefight analysis and prediction



Fight: Lucas Matthysse (36-3-0-1, 34 KOs) vs. Ruslan Provodnikov (24-3, 17 KOs)
Location: Turning Stone Resort and Casino, Verona, New York
Date: April 18, 2015
Weight class: Junior welterweight (140 lbs)
Title(s) on the line: None
TV: HBO
Line: Matthysse -165, Provodnikov +155 (5 Dimes, 4/18/15)
Ring Magazine Rankings: Matthysse: #1 ranked junior welterweight, Provodnikov: #3 ranked junior welterweight
Style: Matthysse: Orthodox, Provodnikov: Orthodox



Positives for Matthysse
Negatives for Matthysse
Positives for Provodnikov
Negatives for Provodnikov
Summary/Prediction


Positives for Matthysse

  • Former interim WBC light welterweight champion. Along with Gennady Golovkin and Sergey Kovalev considered one of the best power punchers in boxing and is considered by many to be the most feared power puncher in boxing fighting under 160 lbs. Has legitimate KO power in both hands; 34 out of his 36 victories have come by TKO/KO. Has one of the highest KO% in boxing at 85% (34 wins by TKO/KO out of 40 fights). Arguably one of the top 5 offensive fighters in the sport.
  • Aggressive, come-forward pressure fighter but also has decent, underrated boxing skills. Good combination puncher who throws a wide variety of power punches (overhand rights, straight rights, left hooks) from different angles and punches effectively both to the head and to the body. Cuts off the ring very well (though vs. another pressure fighter like Provodnikov he likely won't need to cut off the ring much, if at all).
  • Has lost only 3 fights in his career - a close but clear unanimous decision loss to current undefeated lightweight champion Danny Garcia, and two highly controversial split decision losses to Devon Alexander and Zab Judah (both Alexander and Judah were knocked down in those fights). These 3 losses were vs. faster, more technically skilled boxers; vs. Provodnikov Matthysse will have the advantage in technical skill and hand speed. Has beaten well-regarded former world champions such as Lamont Peterson, Humberto Soto, and DeMarcus Corley - all by early/mid round TKO/KO.  
  • Overall, is clearly a better boxer than Provodnikov - has superior technical skills, better foot movement, quicker hands, and higher boxing IQ. Will have a 3" reach advantage vs. Provodnikov and is the more accurate, precise, powerful puncher. 
  • Has a decent (though perhaps not great) chin. Has been knocked down 3 times in his last 3 fights (the first 3 knockdowns of his career), but recovered well and never seemed to be in any trouble after getting knocked down.


Negatives for Matthysse

  • Matthysse has shown a fairly good chin in the past but how will his chin hold up on Saturday vs. the most aggressive, relentless power puncher he's fought in his career? Matthysse was knocked down 3 times in recent fights vs. Danny Garcia and John Molina Jr. - neither of whom are nearly as aggressive or relentless as Provodnikov (though Molina has comparable power). There is a high risk Matthysse goes down again in this fight if he does not get to Provodnikov first - it will be interesting to see how Matthysse recovers if this happens.  
  • Matthysse has possibly lost confidence since getting knocked down for the 1st time in his career in his September 2013 fight vs. Garcia (which was the first uncontroversial loss of his career) and has been knocked down two more times since then. Provodnikov is a fiercely determined fighter with seemingly indomitable will who has broken the confidence of top fighters (see his October 2013 fight vs. then WBO light welterweight champion Mike Alvarado).  
  • Employs a fairly effective high guard defense but his aggressive, pressuring style often leaves him out of position and open to counter punching. Not a particularly fast or elusive boxer, so Provodnikov, who is also very effective at cutting off the ring, will have his opportunities to land clean power punches. 
  • Can be outboxed - in particular vs. speedier, technically sound boxers who move well (see his losses vs. Judah, Alexander, and Garcia) though he comes into the fight vs. Provodnikov with a speed and skill advantage so this likely won't be an issue tonight. But Matthysse may not have the technical skill or chin to keep the high volume and effective pressure of Provodnikov at bay.
  • Though in recent fights has improved his work rate in early rounds, Matthysse is known for being a slow starter. Provodnikov will relentlessly pressure Matthysse thoughout the entire 12 round fight so would not be a good idea to get down early on the scorecards in this matchup.


Positives for Provodnikov

  • Former WBO light welterweight champion. High volume pressure fighter with an excellent punch. Superb inside boxer who cuts off the ring well and hits especially hard to the body. Has the ability to knockout any opponent at any time. In March 2013, knocked down Timothy Bradley - who has one of the best chins in boxing - for the first time in his career in the 12th round of their fight, a fight which Ring Magazine named fight of the year. Lost a close unanimous decision victory vs. then #3 pound-for-pound ranked Bradley, a fight some felt he won.
  • Has lost only three times in his career - vs. Bradley, Chris Algieri (June 2014), and Mauricio Herrera (January 2011); all three losses were close, controversial decisions. Has defeated former world champions Jose Luis Castillo (most recent fight), Mike Alvarado, and DeMarcus Corley.
  • Is known for having an excellent chin; has never been knocked down or knocked out in his career.
  • Is a gritty, relentless, durable fighter with excellent stamina. Won't tire in the later rounds of fights. In terms of pure aggression and power will likely give Matthysse the toughest test of his career.
  • Trained for this fight with 7-time BWAA trainer of the year Freddie Roach, under whom he has improved considerably since he began training with him in 2012. (Though because Roach is training Manny Pacquiao for his May 2 fight vs. Floyd Mayweather, Roach's assistant trainer Marvin Samodio will be the lead trainer for tonight's fight vs. Matthysse.) 
  • Humble, likeable boxer from a small village in Siberia with tremendous inner strength and indomitable will to win. Physically tough but even greater mental toughness.
  • Provodnikov's boxing skills, while not as sharp as Matthysse's, are somewhat underrated. He has shown some ability in previous fights to adapt to his opponent's fighting style and make necessary adjustments.

Negatives for Provodnikov

  • Provodnikov comes into this fight having lost two out of his last four fights, his most recent at the hands of relatively unknown and inexperienced Algieri, who was as high as an 8-1 underdog. Provodnikov's two most recent wins were a 5th round TKO vs. a past prime Jose Luis Castillo in Russia and a 10th round victory vs. Alvarado, who has lost four out of his last five fights.
  • How good is Provodnikov's chin? Provodnikov is noted for never having been knocked down or knocked out in his career but he's also never fought a true power puncher in his prime. Provodnikov's three losses (to Algieri, Bradley, and Herrera) have all been against opponents considered relatively feather-fisted. Freddie Roach admitted in interviews during and after the Bradley fight that he almost stopped the fight in the later rounds due to the accumulation of punches Provodnikov was taking; if Provodnikov was almost stopped vs. a light-fisted Bradley how will he fare vs. one of the best power punchers in the sport in Matthysse? The true strength of Provodnikov's chin will be tested in tonight's fight. 
  • Lacks speed and mobility. This was the difference in his losses vs. Algieri and Bradley. In addition to having better boxing skills, Matthysse will have a hand speed and lateral movement advantage vs. Provodnikov, something Provodnikov will have to find a way to overcome if he wants to win this fight.
  • Provodnikov's predictable come-forward approach combined with lack of speed and defensive fundamentals often makes him easy to hit. Provodnikov is more than willing to stand in front of his opponents and take punches to throw punches, which may not work well for him vs. a devastating power puncher like Matthysse, whose only losses have been vs. technically superior fighters who stayed outside of his punching range. 
  • Swells/cuts very easily. Could be an issue as the fight progresses, especially vs. an accurate power puncher like Matthysse.


Prefight Summary

I think this fight ultimately comes down to how well Provodnikov's chin handles Matthysse's massive punching power. Provodnikov certainly has a very real chance to win this fight. He cuts off the ring just as well - if not better than - Matthysse and will attack Lucas with a combination of relentless aggression and power the likes of which Matthysse has never seen before in his career. Matthysse is not nearly as mobile as Algieri or Bradley (who handed Provodnikov his most recent losses) so he will be forced quite often to stand toe-to-toe with Provodnikov and slug it out. In a brawl such as this, it is largely a matter of which boxer has the greatest punching power, willpower, and chin. Provodnikov I believe has advantages in two out of these three attributes (willpower and chin) so I think he'll have the advantage if, as many expect, this fight turns into an all-out brawl.


Furthermore, it is possible that Matthysse has lost a bit of confidence in both his chin and punching power since losing to Danny Garcia; in that fight (in which Matthysse was listed as a 1-3 favorite), he was knocked down for the first time in his career and it was the first time he failed to knock down or knock out an opponent in over four years (over a span of 14 fights). In the fight following the Garcia fight, Matthysse was surprisingly knocked down two more times by 9-1 underdog John Molina Jr., who has comparable power to Provodnikov, but is not nearly as high volume or aggressive a puncher. If Provodnikov can turn this fight into a brawl and his chin is as good as advertised, there is a very good chance he'll wear Matthysse down and win this fight by TKO/KO in the mid to late rounds.



But I think the key point in evaluating this fight is noting that Provodnikov, while credited for having a great chin, has never fought anyone with Matthysse's brute punching power before. I can't help but think back to Freddie Roach admitting during the fight vs. Bradley that he was close to stopping the fight due to the punishment Provodnikov was taking. Admittedly, Bradley has top-level hand speed so can get his punches and combinations off quicker than Matthysse but he is also notorious for being a light puncher, having only 12 KOs in 34 career fights. If Provodnikov was in danger of being stopped vs. a feather-fisted Tim Bradley, I can't help but think he will be in for a very long night vs. one of the most accurate and heavy-handed power punchers in the sport, a fighter who has taken 34 of his 36 career wins by TKO/KO.


Provodnikov's come-forward, aggressive style will frequently leave him open to clean power punching over the course of the fight. Matthysse's hand speed is a bit faster than Provodnikov's so I see his punches generally landing first (before Provodnikov has a chance to land his) and landing more accurately, given Provodnikov's tendency to throw wild punches. I think we may find that Provodnikov's chin isn't quite as unbreakable as people think after being tested tonight by one of the best power punchers in the sport. This fight will largely be a matter of who gets to who first; I like Matthysse's power vs. a relatively slow, defensively negligient Provodnikov and think he will display just enough boxing skill and movement to keep Ruslan's power at bay. If Matthysse doesn't stop Provodnikov late, I like Lucas to win a competitive but clear unanimous decision victory.


But either way this fight should be a wildly entertaining fight-of-the-year (if not decade) level match-up that every boxing fan, whether hardcore or casual, should look forward to watching!


Prediction: Matthysse to win 


  for additional boxing analysis and to be notified of new blog updates!!!

Friday, April 10, 2015

Garcia vs. Peterson: prefight analysis and prediction



Fight: Danny Garcia (29-0, 17 KOs) vs. Lamont Peterson (33-2-1, 17 KOs)
Location: Barclays Center, Brooklyn, New York, New York
Date: April 11, 2015
Weight class: Welterweight (147 lbs); fight is being fought at a catchweight of 143 lbs
Title(s) on the line: None
TV: NBC
Line: Garcia -400, Peterson +325 (5 Dimes, 4/10/15)
Purse: Garcia: $1.5 million, Peterson: $1.2 million
Ring Magazine Rankings: Garcia: junior welterweight champion, Peterson: #2 ranked junior welterweight
Style: Garcia: Orthodox, Peterson: Orthodox

Positives for Garcia
Negatives for Garcia
Positives for Peterson
Negatives for Peterson
Summary/Prediction


Positives for Garcia

  • Undefeated boxer (29-0) and current WBC, WBA Super, and Ring Magazine light welterweight (140 lbs) champion. Poised, patient counterpuncher with good power who has overachieved considerably in becoming an undefeated world champion and one of the best boxers in the sport. Only 27 years old (over 4 years younger than Peterson) and currently in the prime of his career. 
  • Smart, seemingly unflappable boxer with solid boxing skills and hand speed who generally positions himself well in executing his versatile attack. Overall well-rounded boxer with no true glaring weaknesses.
  • Has very underrated, dangerous punching power, despite only having 17 KOs in 29 fights (58.6%). Garcia has knocked down 6 of his last 7 opponents, knocking them down a total of 10 times. Garcia's knockouts usually come courtesy of his left hook, which is by far his best punch (and happens to be one of the best left hooks, if not the best left hook, in the sport). 
  • Has consistently risen to the occasion to beat top quality opponents such as Erik Morales (twice), Amir Khan, Zab Judah, and Lucas Matthysse. Was a significant underdog vs. Khan, who he knocked down 3 times en route to a 4th round TKO victory in July 2012 and vs. elite power puncher Matthysse, who he knocked down once en route to a competitive but clear unanimous decision win on the Floyd Mayweather vs. Canelo Alvarez undercard in September 2013. In defeating Matthysse, Garcia defeated an opponent who'd just defeated Peterson by 3rd round TKO a few months prior.
  • Strong, durable fighter with an excellent chin. Has never been knocked down or knocked out in his career.
  • Of Puerto Rican descent (both parents are from Puerto Rico) and will be fighting in New York City, a city only a couple hours from his hometown of Philadelphia and known for its large Puerto Rican population. The crowd at Barclays Center will likely be pro-Garcia.


Negatives for Garcia

  • Arguably overrated fighter whose recent wins perhaps aren't all as impressive as they appear to be on paper. In a span of a little over a year beat future first ballot hall-of-famer Morales twice and 5-time world champion Judah, but both opponents were well past their primes at the time of those fights. Most felt Garcia lost his March 2014 majority decision victory vs. tough but light-hitting journeyman Mauricio Herrera in front of a heavily pro-Garcia crowd in Puerto Rico. Has been widely accused of avoiding top quality opponents in recent fights.
  • Has pretty good boxing skills but is not an elite technician and is capable of being outboxed. Has arguably been outboxed for stretches of numerous fights, including his fight with Herrera, the early rounds of his first fight vs. Morales, the early rounds of his fight vs. Khan, and his close split-decision victory vs. Ashley Theophane in February 2010.
  • Garcia's nickname, "Swift," is somewhat of a misnomer; while he has good hand speed, he is a bit flat-footed. In Peterson, Garcia will be facing a technically superior boxer who moves well around the ring. 
  • In executing his attack, sometimes neglects defense which can make him easy to hit. 


Positives for Peterson

  • Former WBA Super and current IBF light welterweight champion. Experienced, clever boxer with a solid amateur pedigree (including National Golden Gloves championship at lightweight back in 2001). Has suffered only two losses in his career - the first in December 2009 to then undefeated and current Ring Magazine #6 pound-for-pound fighter Timothy Bradley and most recently in May 2013 to highly regarded power puncher Lucas Matthysse.   
  • Technically solid, legit world-class fighter with good speed, footwork, and endurance. Adept at making adjustments during fights and generally fights better in the mid to late rounds as he wears his opponents down. Comes into this fight vs. Garcia as the technically superior boxer. 
  • Adept using the jab (in particular his left jab, which is his best punch) and foot movement to control distance and outbox opponents from the outside but is also capable of coming forward and applying pressure on the inside, as demonstrated in his December 2011 upset victory over Khan to win his current IBF lightweight championship. 
  • Relatively tall, lanky fighter who will enter the ring with a slight size and 3.5" reach advantage vs. Garcia. If Peterson uses his reach and sticks with his jab (a punch which gave Garcia numerous problems in his recent controversial win vs. Herrera) it could spell trouble for Garcia.
  • Since his TKO loss vs. Mattysse, has performed impressively in his most recent fights vs. then undefeated Dierry Jean and Edgar Santana.
  • Not a big puncher (as evidenced by his 47.2% KO ratio), but applies pressure well and punches hard enough to make opponents respect the decent power he has.


Negatives for Peterson

  • Peterson has for a long time been regarded as one of the better boxers in the sport but has generally not fared well vs. top-level competition. Suffered decisive losses when stepping up in competition vs. Bradley and Matthysse and had to fight his way back in later rounds to earn a draw vs. Victor Ortiz in December 2010. Scored upset split decision victory vs. Khan in his hometown of D.C. to win the WBA Super and IBF light welterweight titles but the judging and refereeing during the fight (which included 2 point deductions from Khan) was regarded by many as highly questionable. Peterson was stripped of the WBA Super light welterweight title shortly before a scheduled May 2012 rematch with Khan due to testing positive for synthetic testosterone - which cast doubt on his performance in the first fight with Khan. Other than Khan, Peterson's best win was an 8th round TKO of former world champion Kendall Holt.      
  • Questionable defense and chin. Peterson has been knocked down 7 times in his last 4 fights vs. high-profile opponents (knocked down three times in his 3rd round TKO loss vs. Matthysse, once vs. Khan, twice vs. Ortiz, and even once vs. Bradley - who is notorious for his lack of punching power). At times can be easy to hit; sometimes drops his hands during exchanges, which could leave him wide open for Garcia's vicious left hook.
  • Peterson has a tendency to start fights slowly while adjusting to his opponent; Peterson can get away with slow starts vs. lesser opponents but against a higher-level opponent like Garcia the first few rounds could be the difference in the fight. 
  • Has decent, but not great power, as evidenced by the fact that he's only scored 17 TKO/KO victories in 36 professional fights (47.2% KO ratio). Garcia has an excellent chin so if Peterson is going to win this fight, he'll have to win by decision.

Prefight Summary

To be honest, Peterson is probably the better boxer in this matchup. He has more experience, is more technically skilled, and will be the (slightly) bigger man coming into the fight. Peterson's reach advantage combined with his potent jab, speed, and footwork should pose major problems for Garcia, especially if Peterson stays outside and fights the patient, smart fight he's capable of fighting. Garcia has been outboxed in stretches numerous times in the past vs. opponents of Peterson's caliber (or even a bit worse) and has shown a particular susceptibility to jabs in a recent, hugely controversial split decision victory vs. Herrera (most felt he lost that fight), a fighter not as well regarded as Peterson.

I wouldn't be surprised at all to see Peterson, currently listed as an over 3-1 underdog, score the upset victory in a fight I'd grade him as having a 35-40% chance to win - especially if he can get through the early rounds as he tends to fight better in later rounds as he adjusts to his opponents.

But I see the combination of Garcia's sneaky power and Peterson's shaky chin being the difference in this fight. I believe Garcia, who is a patient, very solid all-around boxer in his own right, will eventually catch Peterson with his patented combinations and left hooks. Unlike Herrera, who has an excellent chin (as evidenced by the fact that he's never been knocked down or knocked out in his career), Garcia's power will affect Peterson's ability to execute his attack... especially given that Peterson is prone to applying pressure to his opponents, which should set up spots for clean counterpunching from Garcia. This, combined with the fact that Peterson is a slow starter to begin with and the fact that Garcia has time and again stepped up big in high-profile fights, compels me to give the edge to Garcia. But given Peterson's solid foot movement and the fact that Garcia isn't an overly aggressive power puncher I think it's more likely Garcia wins the fight by decision rather than by TKO/KO.

If I was betting this fight, I'd take the bet on Garcia to win by decision but the odds on Peterson to win by decision (+480 on 5 Dimes) are so attractive that I'd strongly recommend placing a smaller amount on Peterson by decision as a hedge play. Would even consider Peterson by decision as the primary play, given that +480 is an excellent price for a fighter I'd grade as having a 35-40% chance to pull off the upset.


Prediction: Garcia by decision 

[Recommended Hedge: Peterson by decision (+480)] 

  for additional boxing analysis and to be notified of new blog updates!!!